Skip to main content


* indicates required

You can Translate article here

The final Cut

By Sudish Kamath

Though uphill, the battle against the censor board is one that must be fought by filmmakers given how toothless the government has been in saving their work from scissor-happy autocrats

If culture is the new opium of the people, the chief of the Central Board for Film Certification Pahlaj Nihalani is the drug lord controlling all business in this town.

Udta Punjab is the latest example of the autocratic, arbitrary nature of the unchallenged power given to the certification body that continues to censor films under assorted excuses. This time around, it has a problem with profanity, drug use and representation of Punjab and Punjabis.

Last year, after The Hindu leaked a recorded conversation where Nihalani is heard dictating what he thinks are permissible words for adults, the CBFC chief completely banned phones or cameras or any recording device in his cabin.

Mr. Nihalani was heard offering dubbing solutions to the young filmmakers. “You can dub g**** with Mirchi and Mother***** can be dubbed as maikalaal.”

Rajyavardhan Rathore, Minister of State for Information and Broadcasting, met the film industry about 16 months agowith a promise that “things will get better.”

Mukesh Bhatt, President of the Film and TV Producers Guild of India, rather naively, believed that it was the most fruitful meeting with the Ministry in years.

Pahlaj Nihalani took charge in January 2015.

Somewhere in the middle of these 18 months of Pahlaj-run CBFC, I had my own first hand experience of the autocracy when my serialised anthology ‘X Past is Present’ — directed by 11 filmmakers — was screened for certification in the first week of November 2015. The idea was to build a bridge between the different cinemas of India.

Being a former journalist, I decided to record the post-screening cut negotiation with the CBFC’s examining committee. After being told to adhere to Pahlaj’s guidelines on profanity, we pleaded to the examining committee to allow cuss-words only in Kaushik Mukherjee’s portion of the film given that Q (as Kaushik is known) represented the underground, anti-establishment cinema in the country.

We argued that it would be unfair to the filmmaker to mute the voice of angst especially when the character is off-screen.

The committee then reviewed the portion of the film we had appealed for exemption. To our relief, they agreed to let us retain the profanity for Q’s portion. Or so we thought.

We executed the cuts on the basis of the recorded negotiation in the absence of an official cut-list and submitted the DVD as proof of cuts made. The CBFC gave us a Censor certificate on November 18 (for the November 20 release) and also issued the official show cause (cut-list) on the same date - ONE week after the submission of cuts. Except that the time-code of the exemption they had agreed upon and time-code of the exemption mentioned in the list didn’t quite match.

When we requested for the corrected cut-list as per our recording, we were told not to ever mention that we had recorded the negotiation because that would upset the CBFC chief.

After making us wait for a couple of hours and making us deposit our phones outside, Nihalani met us for one whole minute.

Within that window, we made our case. We told him we had submitted a DVD with the cuts as agreed upon to the best of our understanding in the absence of a written cut list. If those were not the cuts that were agreed upon, how and why would the CBFC issue a certificate?

He called the examining officer to re-open the sealed DVD and re-issue the list according “to the records”.

In the next ten minutes, the DVD was played back to us and we pointed out how it was consistent to our understanding of the negotiation. But the five members of the examining committee had signed off to the erroneous cut-list that exempted one minute that didn’t feature any profanity.

The officer then told us: “Obviously, there’s some confusion or misunderstanding. But since five members have signed, you have to follow this cut-list. We cannot call them back for a review now. You have to go to the revising committee.” We had spent all of November 19 at the CBFC office to be told this. With four hours to go for the premiere.

We reminded him that we already had our certificate in hand and released the film consistent with the cuts we had submitted. When the DVD is ever opened in court, it would become obvious that the CBFC made a mistake.

But take a moment to let this sink in.

The CBFC had indeed issued a censor certificate without exactly knowing what the cuts or exemptions were.

All the more arbitrary was the fact that the CBFC later refused to recertify the film as UA for TV because of the theme (filmmaker haunted by memories of the women in his life) and the studio didn’t want to challenge it.

The truth is that most studios and production companies in India do not budget for the time (three months to a year) and money (anywhere between a lakh to 10 per cent of production budget) it takes to fight the autocracy of CBFC through the available channels – including the Film Certification Appellate Tribunal and then different levels of courts.

Though each cut-list refers to Pahlaj’s guidelines as “recommendations,” they are hardly just that. Recommendation makes the courts believe that the CBFC merely suggested these cuts and the filmmakers made these cuts out of their own free will. But the truth is that certification is denied until the cuts are made.

According to reports, the CBFC has given no official show-cause of cuts YET for Udta Punjab. Cuts are “conveyed.”

Nothing on paper that can be published or leaked to the media. Nothing that can even be remotely used as proof of cultural policing.

Every filmmaker who wants to preserve his artistic integrity will need to make going to court the norm and say no to cuts and cultural bullying. Though uphill, it’s a battle that needs to be fought in the courts given how toothless the government has been in saving films from scissor-happy autocrats. Minister Rajyavardhan Rathore is yet to walk the talk.

When the government is unable to withhold Article 19 and provide artists the basic right of freedom of speech and expression, it’s time to rethink support to political parties that are pro-censorship.

The Shyam Benegal led committeesubmitted its recommendations for the revamp of the CBFC in April.

The government is still sitting on it.


Popular Posts of the Week

Facts about Daman & Diu

Daman and Diu. Union Territory of Daman and Diu comprises two districts namely Daman and Diu. Both Districts are situated on western coast of India at a distance of about 700 kms. Daman is the head Quarter of this U.T. Daman is on main land near southern portion of Gujarat State. Vapi is the nearest Railway Station (13 kms) which is on Western Railway between Mumbai and Surat. Vapi is 167 kms from Mumbai Central and 95 kms from Surat.

GK Update 1 July 2016

1. Suresh Prabhu launches NIVARAN portal i. Shri Suresh Prabhakar Prabhu, Minister of Railways  has launched "NIVARAN portal", an online system for redressal of service related grievance of serving and former railway employees.  ii. Nivaran portal is an online system that seeks to facilitate the employees to lodge their grievances and also monitor the progress. iii. It has been developed by CRIS (Centre for Railway information systems), an IT arm of Indian Railways on basis of process designed by Establishment directorate of Railway Board. 2. Indigenously built Tejas inducted into IAF i. The Indian Air Force (IAF) inducted the first squadron of the indigenously made Light Combat Aircraft (LCA) Tejas into its fleet.  ii. An induction ceremony to induct two Tejas aircrafts was held at the Aircraft Systems Testing Establishment (ASTE) in Bengaluru, which included a multi religious prayer. iii. The crew members of the first squadron of Tejas, a multi-role supersonic single


On 16th January 2015, New year will be super thrilling as Bipasha Basu is coming with her new movie "Alone" which looks another superb horror movie of Bollywood . Alone Movie Poster The trailer has come out and looking very scary and wonderful and by the trailer it looks like that the movie is based on two sisters who are joint with their bodies but after a operation one of them died and turn into evil.

What are some rules in Corporate life?

1. Always loop your boss in every mail 2. Politics is everywhere, learn to navigate it 3. Always aim to complete YOUR WORK by a 180%, that way it will be more than a 110% and your boss can’t question you. 4. There is always time at office, use it to upgrade your skills and to plan effectively 5. Network Network Network, who knows your office janitor might lead you to your next job 6. Please everyone around you 7. Learn to say NO, when situation demands 8. Treat the office boy, janitor and IT guy and every one with respect, they might help you in ways you can never imagine 9. Smile, and know people 10. Dress impeccably, over dress when in doubt 11. Documentation is King 12. Practice empathy and respond, never react. 13. Practice patience and learn to listen 14. Requesting for help is one sure shot way to connect with people. 15. Do not speak more than necessary 16. Always enter and leave on time 17. Learn from everyone

Sonia Gandhi is true foreigner

Hello Friends, Today's topic is slightly my personal view not a group view and this is about our Italian political leader Smt.Sonia Gandhi who always claim her to be a true Indian. But i really don't agree with her mentality because she is only wife of Mr. Rajeev Gandhi ,thats all.If she really trust indian people then why she always did her medical check up in United States of America. Are Indian doctors are not well qualified to do her medical check up ? Thats why i really hate Sonia gandhi's attitude as she doesn't trust highly qualified doctors of India.I really doubt on her as she doesn't trust educated doctors then how we believe that she will complete her promises for illiterate people of India. This totally signifies that she just forwarding Congress party for the future of her family and their children.Sonia doesn't know any ABCD about politics and her son Rahul is also same as Rajeev Gandhi was.Our honorable Prime minister Smt. Indi

Top 10 Athletes of the year 2014

Athletes are always been in most searched term of Google search and in year 2014 also, some athletes also won the heart of people all around the world . This list includes mostly Football players and formula 1 players. So today I am posting the Top searched player in year 2014 : James Rodriguez

Is it good to fool people in name of God

Hello friends, Today i have come with another question in my mind i.e "Is it good to fool people in name of God ?". Recently a case on a saint Asaram has shocked all the people of India and foreign also ,that how a old man can do sexual assault of his grand daughter looking like child.At this time , this saint is behind the jail and facing a huge shame in front of  world. But after hearing all this type of news,i am always thinking that why people always follow such illiterate and inappropriate person who is just playing with your sisters/mothers/daughters and also earning for that. You will be shocked after hearing some of the facts of this ASARAM :   1. In early 1970, Asaram built his first ashram on 4 ha (10 acres) of land in Gujarat and began using the name Asaram Bapu. Presently, there are over 400 major and minor ashrams in India and abroad and numerous followers. 2. He preaches the existence of One Supreme Conscious and claims B

Chetan Bhagat launched his new book "Half girlfriend"

Hello Friends, Recently Famous Indian Writer Chetan Bhagat Launched his new book "Half Girlfriend" on 5 August 2014. This book is about two main characters Madhav and Riya. By the teaser, it looks like a story of a couple in which Madhav can't speak English well but want a relationship with Riya. Here is the look of the poster of this new book:


● British Governor-Genera l : Warren Hastings ● British Governor-Genera l of Independent India : Lord Mountbatten ● Justice of India : Hiralal J. Kania ● Comander-in-Chi ef of Free India : General K. M. Cariappa ● Chief of Air Staff : Air Marshal Sir Thomas Elmhirst ● Indian Air Chief : Air Marshal S. Mukherjee ● Chief of Army Staff : General M. Rajendra Singh ● Chief of Naval Staff : Vice-Admiral R. D. Katari ● Consmonaut : Sqn. Ldr. Rakesh Sharma

How a lady Jagriti singh can be such cruel

Hello Friends, Today i am gonna talk about a lady who crosses all her limits of anger and did a unexpected thing in his life,which a lady hardly does in her life. Friends,we know ladies as symbol of beauty,coolness,calmness,responsibleness,helpfulness and kindness.They also show their anger but they do it in non-violent or talkative way. But recently,wife of a BSP MLA Dhananjay singh just proved all these symbols as fake statement.The name of this cruel wife is Jagriti Singh and she is now behind the jail for murdering her maid Rekha Bhadra. Recent investigation of Police is showing,she used to torcher her servants daily for any reason and beat them in a very cruel manner.She beat her servants with rods, wooden bamboo and other stuffs.She also used to watch her under 18 male servant in bathroom by a hidden camera.She also did the shameful work by forcing her servants to drink urine and also there is news that when she tired of beating her servants then she used to give them

Past Trending Posts